I just wanted to emphasise a few points. For example, oxygen will not be all that helpful. In fact, in some cases, we may administer a mixture of 20-30% mixture Oxygen and 70-80% Helium while we try to decrease obstruction with other methods. Also, the absence of wheezing is not always this disastrous silent chest everybody assumes. A person can present with relatively milld symptoms and no wheezing, only to have significant airflow obstruction. This may not even be appreciated until you assess the PEFR and even perform bedside spirometry and you note a significant ice-cream scoop on the flow/volume loop. Asthma is much more complicated and subtle than many assume.
My post was not necessarily related to the topic at hand. If somebody is having trouble with their asthma and I just happen to be a first aider, I will most likely call an ambulance, provide emotional support, obtain a history and transfer my findings to the EMS crew. All this craziness about giving this MDI or that MDI to a patient is not all that relevant as you have pretty much stated. Perhaps, it would apply in some rural situations or outlandish disaster scenarios, but for the most part, I'll wait for EMS.
ERDoc, I am not a huge fan of cancelling orders. While I do believe inhaled bronchodilators are over utilised in the hospital and outside of the hospital, I would need to present a solid case before cancelling an order and I don't believe in going behind a physicians back. What I am not keen on is arbitrarily ordering scheduled bronchodilators on patients. However, I don't necessarily use the absence of wheezing to determine the absence of obstruction. For example, I have mild to moderate obstruction and had likely gone 30+ years with asthma until I was diagnosed a few years back during a PFT. I had crap peak flows and air trapping without any wheezing, but for years I would cough and often clear my throat. I didn't really know how bad I felt until I was treated.